top of page

Same cliff, different verdict: Countryfile and the peregrine double standard

C4PMC
4 minutes ago
2 min read

On Sunday’s Countryfile, Hamza Yassin went to a secret spot near the Moffat Hills to help protect peregrine falcons (watch on iPlayer). The bird was the star. The double standards were the subtext.


By the programme’s own account, the threat to these peregrines is theft. Volunteer George Smith said chicks are stolen to order for falconry, some trafficked to the Middle East, with around six nests lost a year and birds selling for up to £250,000.


Yet gamekeepers still got a mention as persecutors. No estate, case or conviction was named, and no keeper was asked to respond. It was a throwaway line, and it did what throwaway lines do: it pinned a crime on a whole profession without evidence.


The BBC would not let that pass about any other group. It should not let it pass about keepers.



Volunteer Rebecca Dickson called signs of someone climbing down to a monitored nest “horrendous”. In the same programme, volunteers, a presenter and a BBC crew climbed to peregrine nests and took DNA samples from the chicks.


Same ledge. Same chicks. Same specially protected bird. On camera it was a mission; as a set of footprints it was horrendous. Put a keeper on that ledge and it would have been a police appeal and a headline.


Peregrines need protecting from disturbance. That rule should bind the people holding the cameras as firmly as everyone else.


Moorland communities want the thieves caught. What they will not accept is a broadcaster that casts keepers as suspects and conservationists as heroes by default, whatever the evidence.


Countryfile showed where the real threat lies. It should have said so, and left keepers out of it.

 
 

In line with the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) we would like to remind you that  if you sign up we hold your contact information on our secure database. We keep this so that we can update you on our progress and inform you of any events or publications that may be of interest. 

If you would like us to remove your contact details from our database please email contact@c4pmc.co.uk

bottom of page